The review of the official reviewer
 for the dissertation of Raslana Salmanova on the topic: “Transformation of public
administration in the field of urban development”, submitted for a doctorate degree

                in the specialty “6D051000 - State and Local Government”

в„– Criteria                Eligibility (one of the answer options must   Justification of the
p/p                       be checked)                                   position of the
                                                                        official reviewer

1. The topic of the thesis (as 1.1 Compliance with priority areas of science The title of the

of the date of its        development or government programs:           dissertation

approval) corresponds to                                                corresponds to the

the directions of                                                       priority areas of

development of science                                                  science and state

and / or state programs                                                 programs

                          1) The thesis was completed within the        The dissertation was
                          framework of a project or target program      carried out in
                          financed from the state budget (indicate the  accordance with the
                          name and number of the project or program)    strategy "Kazakhstan-
                          2) The thesis was completed within the        2050: a new political
                          framework of another state program (indicate  course of the
                          the name of the program)                      established state", the
                          3) The thesis corresponds to the priority     National
                          direction of the development of science,      Development Plan of
                          approved by the Higher Scientific and         the Republic of
                          Technical Commission under the Government     Kazakhstan until
                          of the Republic of Kazakhstan (indicate the   2025, The State
                          direction)                                    program "Digital
                                                                        Kazakhstan"

2. Importance for science The work makes / does not make a significant The dissertation

                          contribution to science, and its importance is advances the

                          well disclosed/not disclosed                  scholarly

                                                                        understanding of how

                                                                        the Kazakhstani

                                                                        public administration

                                                                        has evolved and

                                                                        changed in the field of

                                                                        urban development.

                                                                        The study also

                                                                        performs rich data

                                                                        analyses that provide

                                                                        a clear indication of

                                                                        the changes that may

                                                                        be required to

                                                                        improve the urban

                                                                        development process

                                                                        and increase citizen

                                                                        satisfaction

3. The principle of       Self-reliance level:                          The dissertation
       independence       1) High;                                      reveals an original
                          2) Medium;                                    thinking of the
                          3) Low;                                       doctoral student, a
                          4) No independence                            collection of a wide
                                                                        range of interesting
                                                                        data, and very precise
                                                                        analyses of legal and